Rolex rewrote the Cookie Monster vs Smurf comparison at Watches & Wonders 2026. It dropped the white-gold Submariner Date 126619LB, the “Cookie Monster,” from its catalog. The Smurf left in 2020.
So both are retired now. In 2026, a Cookie Monster trades around $38,000 and a Smurf around $42,000, even though the Cookie Monster is the newer watch. That flip is the most interesting part of this comparison.
Below, we cover what each watch is, how they differ on the wrist, what they cost now, and which one fits the way you’ll wear it. Start with the Cookie Monster, since it’s the one that just changed.
What Is the Rolex Submariner “Cookie Monster”
The Rolex Cookie Monster is the white-gold Submariner Date reference 126619LB, with a black dial and a blue Cerachrom bezel, made from 2020 until Rolex discontinued it in 2026. The name came from collectors, not Rolex, as a nod to the Sesame Street character’s dark face and bright blue fur.
Released in 2020, the 126619LB replaced the Smurf and moved the white-gold Sub into the current Submariner generation.
The black dial is what owners notice day to day. Next to the blue bezel, it tones the whole watch down, which suits buyers who don’t want their watch to announce itself.
Editor note (remove before publishing): keep the existing “From our inventory” Cookie Monster product card here.
Editor note (remove before publishing): add one or two lines from the team’s own handling of this watch here, such as a measured weight on our scale, how the Glidelock clasp feels in use, or what bracelets typically look like when one comes in. Only add what we’ve observed firsthand.
What Is the Rolex Smurf?
The Rolex Smurf is the Submariner Date 116619LB, a 40mm white-gold Sub with a blue dial and blue Cerachrom bezel, made from 2008 to 2020. It was the first Submariner Rolex made entirely in white gold, which gives it a real place in the model’s modern history, whatever you think of the color.
The blue is brighter than earlier blue Subs, and the dial is lacquered rather than sunburst. In good light it has a glossy, almost wet look that suits a dive watch. The Maxi-Dial markers are larger than on older Subs, and the case uses the “Super Case” design of that era.
Key Features
- Reference: 116619LB
- Case: 40mm 18k white gold; Super Case proportions with broad lugs
- Bezel: Blue Cerachrom dive bezel; unidirectional, 60-minute scale
- Dial: Blue lacquered Maxi-Dial matching the bezel
- Bracelet: Solid-link Oyster bracelet in 18k white gold
- Movement: Caliber 3135
- Power Reserve: about 48 hours
- Lume: Chromalight blue glow
- Functions: Time and date with Cyclops lens
- Water Resistance: 300m / 1,000ft
- Production: 2008 to 2020 (discontinued)
- Significance: Rolex’s first white-gold Submariner
A Quick Note on the “Smurf” Name Confusion
Some dealers now call the 126619LB a “Smurf” or “Blueberry” too, which makes search listings confusing. Purists keep the original Smurf name for the blue-on-blue 116619LB and call the 126619LB the Cookie Monster. We use the names that way throughout this guide.
On Chrono24 you’ll see both nicknames attached to the 126619LB, so always check the reference number, not the nickname. We unpack the Cookie Monster vs Blueberry naming question in a separate guide.
Rolex Cookie Monster vs Smurf: Key Differences Explained
The 126619LB and 116619LB share the same Submariner DNA. Four things separate them in daily wear and resale.
Dial and Bezel Color
The Cookie Monster pairs a black dial with the blue bezel. It’s higher contrast and easier to read at a glance. From across a room it can pass for a steel Submariner with a blue bezel, and only the close-up look and the weight give away the white gold. That low-key look is a big part of its appeal.
The Smurf goes the other way. Blue dial, blue bezel, fully monochromatic. It’s the louder of the two and instantly recognizable. If the blue dial is the reason you’re buying, the Smurf gives you that without compromise.
Case Size and Wear
The Smurf uses the older 40mm Super Case with broader lugs and a 20mm lug width. It wears chunkier than the diameter suggests because of the lug thickness and the white-gold weight, and it sits taller on the wrist than the modern Sub.
The Cookie Monster’s 41mm case is the more comfortable wear for most people despite being a millimeter wider. The lugs are slimmer, the 21mm lug width balances better with the bracelet, and the weight spreads more evenly. If you’ve worn a current steel Sub, it will feel familiar.
Movement
The Smurf runs Caliber 3135, the movement Rolex used across the Submariner range for decades. It has about 48 hours of power reserve, and every Rolex watchmaker knows it inside out. Plenty of collectors prefer it for exactly that reason.
The Cookie Monster runs Caliber 3235, with Rolex’s Chronergy escapement and about 70 hours of reserve. Take it off Friday night and it’s still running Monday morning. The escapement parts are made in nickel-phosphorus, which resists magnetism better than the older design.
On the wrist, you won’t feel a difference between the two. We break down what a Rolex Submariner service costs and cover the bigger picture in our breakdown of Rolex movements.
Production Run and Supply
The Smurf had a 12-year run, from 2008 to 2020. The Cookie Monster had six years, from 2020 to 2026. More years usually means more watches in circulation, so the Smurf’s population is larger and the Cookie Monster’s is smaller.
Rolex doesn’t publish production numbers, so nobody outside the company knows the exact gap.
What Changed for Both Watches in 2026
Rolex removed the 126619LB from its catalog at Watches & Wonders 2026 in April. It went out alongside both “Pepsi” GMT-Master II references, the steel 126710BLRO and the white-gold 126719BLRO. The Pepsi news took most of the headlines, so the Cookie Monster’s exit got far less attention.
That shift changes three things for buyers. Here’s how each one plays out:
- The authorized dealer route is closed. Unworn examples with 2026-dated warranty cards on the secondary market are now the closest thing to buying new.
- The Cookie Monster’s supply is fixed. Every example that will ever exist has already been made.
- White gold is gone from the Submariner catalog. If you want a white-gold Sub specifically, these two references and their pre-owned market are the whole menu.
What Replaced the Cookie Monster?
Nothing has replaced it: Rolex launched no new white-gold Submariner in 2026, so the current lineup has no white-gold Sub at all. The Submariner range hasn’t added a new reference since its 2020 update.
If you want a precious-metal Sub with a blue bezel from current production, your options are the yellow-gold 126618LB, with a blue dial and blue bezel, and the two-tone 126613LB “Bluesy.” Both read louder than the Cookie Monster, because yellow gold shows from across the room. We put the Bluesy and the Smurf side by side in a separate comparison.
That’s why the Cookie Monster matters more now than it did a year ago. Its quiet, steel-like look is no longer in the catalog. If white gold matters more to you than the Submariner itself, our roundup of the best white gold watches covers other options.
Rolex Cookie Monster vs Smurf Prices in 2026
Discontinuation didn’t push the Cookie Monster above retail. Prices moved up, but buyers still pay well below what Rolex charged.
The Cookie Monster (126619LB) last listed at $52,100 at Rolex. In 2026 its market value sits around $38,200, up about 8.6% over the past year, according to the Loupe market tracker. That’s still roughly 27% under retail.
At its low point, it traded around $35,000, according to Hodinkee. The market has made back some ground since then, but it’s nowhere near retail.
The Smurf (116619LB) sits around $42,300 in 2026, up about 14.2% over the past year on the same tracker. It has been out of production since 2020, and the market has had time to price that in.
The older Smurf costs about $4,000 more than the newer Cookie Monster, even with the older case and the 48-hour movement. That premium is the market paying for the original white-gold Sub and the blue dial, not the spec sheet.
For a Cookie Monster buyer, the signal runs the other way. You get the newer case and movement for less, before the market fully prices in the fixed supply. There’s no guarantee the gap to retail closes, and so far it has narrowed only a little.
Within each reference, a few details move the price by thousands. Check these before you compare two listings:
- Full set. Box, warranty card, and paperwork. Missing papers mean a lower price now and a harder sale later.
- Card date. Unworn Cookie Monsters with 2026-dated cards sit near the top of the range because they’re from the final batch.
- Polish. An unpolished white-gold case keeps sharper lug edges, and collectors pay more for it.
- Bracelet stretch. Solid white-gold links still wear at the pins, so check how much the bracelet sags when you hold it flat.
These are 2026 market values and they move week to week, so check live Chrono24 listings before you buy. For broader context, see how Rolex values hold up over time.
If you’d like to compare real examples instead of listing photos, message us and we’ll send tour videos and condition notes on the Cookie Monster or Smurf pieces we have available.
Side-by-Side Comparison (A Quick Glance)
The table below lines up the two references most white-gold Sub buyers compare. Both share the same Submariner base, so the contrast comes down to design, proportions, status, and price.
| Feature | Cookie Monster (126619LB) | Smurf (116619LB) |
| Production | 2020 to 2026 | 2008 to 2020 |
| Status | Discontinued 2026 | Discontinued 2020 |
| Case | 41mm 18k white gold | 40mm 18k white gold |
| Lug Width | 21mm | 20mm |
| Dial | Black | Blue (lacquered) |
| Bezel | Blue Cerachrom | Blue Cerachrom |
| Movement | Caliber 3235 | Caliber 3135 |
| Power Reserve | About 70 hours | About 48 hours |
| Water Resistance | 300m / 1,000ft | 300m / 1,000ft |
| 2026 Market Value | About $38,200 | About $42,300 |
| Style | Quiet, reads like steel | Bold, all blue |
Should You Buy the Rolex Cookie Monster or the Smurf?
Buy the Cookie Monster for the modern case and the lower price; buy the Smurf if you want the all-blue original and don’t mind paying about $4,000 more for it. Both are rated to 300m and both are out of production, so the choice comes down to design and case era.
The Cookie Monster fits the buyer who wants the modern case and movement and the quieter dial. It’s the more wearable of the two for most people.
The Smurf fits the buyer who wants the look that started the white-gold Submariner story and likes the older 40mm proportions. Many collectors also see the 3135’s long service record as a plus.
Choose the Cookie Monster If
- You want the current 41mm case with slimmer lugs and the 70-hour Caliber 3235
- You’d rather your white-gold watch look quiet than loud
- You want the lower price and don’t need it to climb back to retail
- The black dial with blue bezel is the design you want, not just the value angle
Choose the Smurf If
- You want the all-blue monochromatic look
- You care about owning the first white-gold Submariner
- You’re fine paying a premium for a watch that’s up about 14% this past year
- The 40mm Super Case proportions appeal to you more than the modern 41mm
More Submariners
2026 NEW UNWORN Rolex Submariner Black Dial Black Ceramic Bezel Stainless Steel Oyster Bracelet 41mm COMPLETE SET 124060-0001
Rolex Submariner Date "Bluesy" Royal Blue Dial Blue Ceramic Bezel Oyster Bracelet Two-Tone 18K Yellow Gold Stainless Steel 41mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 126613LB
2026 NEW UNWORN Rolex Submariner Date Starbucks Black Dial Green Ceramic Bezel Stainless Steel 41mm COMPLETE SET 126610LV-0002
Rolex Submariner Date Black Dial Black Ceramic Bezel Oyster Bracelet Stainless Steel 41mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 126610LN
Rolex Submariner Date "Smurf" Blue Dial Blue Bezel Oyster Bracelet 18K White Gold 40mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 116619LB
Rolex Submariner Date Black Dial Black Bezel Stainless Steel 40mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 16610
Where to Buy Authentic Watches Online
For either reference, a handful of legitimate online channels are worth knowing. Chrono24 is the largest pre-owned watch marketplace, with wide inventory, dealer ratings, and buyer protection on larger transactions.
eBay runs an Authenticity Guarantee program for watches over $2,000, where every Rolex passes through a third-party authenticator before it reaches you. Grailzee runs auction-style sales with vetted sellers if you prefer bidding.
Independent grey-market dealers and watch forums also list both references regularly, though checking the seller matters more outside the big marketplaces. If Chrono24 is your main channel, our guide on what to watch for on Chrono24 covers seller vetting and listing red flags.
We also sell, buy, and trade luxury watches. Clients choose us over a big marketplace, especially for a discontinued reference like either of these, because of the layered communication before they decide.
You get a tour video of the actual watch you’d be buying, not a stock photo. You also get detailed condition notes on the case, bracelet, dial, and bezel, plus a direct conversation with someone who has handled the piece in person.
That’s reflected in our 4.9-star Google rating, which comes from clients who appreciate that walkthrough before committing $40,000 or more to a watch.
If you want that kind of walkthrough on a Cookie Monster or a Smurf, reach out and we’ll line up options that match your spec preferences and condition standards. You can also browse our current collection to see what’s in stock.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Rolex Cookie Monster discontinued?
Yes, Rolex discontinued the Cookie Monster 126619LB at Watches & Wonders 2026, ending a six-year production run. If you see one listed as new, it’s an unworn secondary-market example, usually with a 2026-dated card. The 2026 section above covers what that means for supply.
Will the Cookie Monster go up in value?
Nobody can promise that, but its setup looks a lot like the Smurf’s after 2020: fixed supply and no white-gold replacement. The Smurf’s price is up about 14% over the past year, though it was close to flat for several years before that. So even the Smurf took a while to move.
The Cookie Monster also started from a much higher retail price, so it has more ground to make up. Buy it because you want to wear it, and treat any price gain as a bonus.
How can you tell a White-Gold Sub from Steel?
Weight is the quickest tell: pick either watch up and it feels noticeably heavier than a steel Submariner. From a distance, most people can’t tell, especially with the Cookie Monster.
If you’re buying from a listing, ask the seller for a close photo of the gold hallmarks inside the clasp and for the warranty card, which names the reference. We compare white gold vs stainless steel on Rolex in more detail in a separate guide.
Which is better for smaller wrists?
The Smurf, by a small margin, because it’s 40mm against the Cookie Monster’s 41mm. That millimeter shows on a 6.5-inch wrist. The catch is the Smurf’s thicker Super Case lugs, which add visual mass, so in practice the two wear closer than the spec sheet suggests.
If you can, try both on before deciding. Wrist fit on a $40,000 watch is worth the trip. For other options, see our picks for the best dive watches for smaller wrists.
999+ Timepieces Available
Explore Our Timepieces
Authenticated, unworn, and ready to ship worldwide.
Rolex ┬╖ Audemars Piguet ┬╖ Patek Philippe ┬╖ Omega ┬╖ Cartier ┬╖ Richard Mille ┬╖ Hublot ┬╖ Tudor
Newly Listed
Glash├╝tte Original Seventies Chronograph Panorama Date тАЬDisco BlueтАЭ Stainless Steel Bracelet 40mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 1-37-02-10-02-70
$19,871.00
Glash├╝tte Original Seventies Chronograph Panorama Date тАЬDisco BlueтАЭ Black Rubber Strap Stainless Steel 40mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 1-37-02-10-02-63
$18,925.00
2026 Rolex Land-Dweller White Honeycomb Motif Dial 18K White Gold Fluted Bezel Flat Jubilee Bracelet Stainless Steel 40mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 127334-0001
$25,898.00
2026 NEW UNWORN Rolex Datejust Green Roman Dial 18K Rose Gold Fluted Bezel Two Tone Jubilee 36mm COMPLETE SET 126231-0051
$22,523.00
2022 Rolex Cosmograph Daytona White Dial Two-Tone Steel Yellow Gold 40mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 116503-0001
$24,995.00
Rolex Datejust Olive Green Roman Diamond VI & IX Dial Fluted Bezel Jubilee Bracelet Yellow Gold & Stainless Steel 36mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 126233
$20,695.00
Rolex Yacht-Master II White Dial Blue Ceramic Bezel Oyster Bracelet 18K Yellow Gold 44mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 116688
$41,990.00
2026 NEW UNWORN Tudor Royal Chocolate Roman Dial Two-Tone Yellow Gold Steel 38mm COMPLETE SET 28503-0007
$4,736.00
Patek Philippe Aquanaut Travel Time Opaline Blue-Gray Dial Blue-Gray Composite Strap 18K Rose Gold 38.8mm MINT CONDITION COMPLETE SET 5269R-001
$103,950.00
2026 Rolex Datejust Green Ombr├й Dial White Gold Fluted Bezel Jubilee Bracelet Stainless Steel 36mm MINT CONDITON COMPLETE SET 126234-0059
$17,215.00
2026 NEW UNWORN Rolex Lady-Datejust Pink Dial Diamond Markers 18k White Gold Fluted Bezel Jubilee Stainless Steel 28mm COMPLETE SET 279174
$19,768.00
2026 NEW UNWORN Rolex Datejust 31 Pink Dial Oyster Bracelet Stainless Steel 31mm COMPLETE SET 278240
$13,046.00
Final Thoughts on Rolex Cookie Monster vs Smurf
Both are 18k white-gold, 300m Submariners, and both are now out of production. The Cookie Monster is the quieter, more comfortable modern wear. The Smurf is the louder original, and the one collectors pay more for.
Two tips before you buy. White gold is softer than steel, so ask whether the case has been polished and request a light touch at service. Our polished vs unpolished breakdown covers the trade-off. And ask the seller for a timegrapher reading, so you know how it’s running before you pay.
For the whole range, see our Rolex Submariner buying guide.
